Morsa publishes this guide. Morsa is software with an AI agent that works in your ERP, email and Teams; it scores suppliers from POs, and a person approves what goes out.
The four supplier performance metrics, with formulas
Sources group supplier metrics into quality, delivery, cost and responsiveness [1]. Start with one measure for each:
Metric | Formula | Example target (ours) |
|---|---|---|
On-time delivery | Lines received by the confirmed date ÷ lines due | 95% |
Quality | Quantity rejected ÷ quantity received × 1,000,000 (ppm) [3] | 250 ppm |
Responsiveness | Average hours from your PO or question to the supplier’s confirmation | 24 hours |
Cost | Lines invoiced at the PO price ÷ lines invoiced | 98% |
A practitioner’s scorecard in IndustryWeek treated 95% on time as the minimum for a qualified supplier and 98% as the level for a certified one [3]. Score against the confirmed date, not the date you wished for, or every late line becomes an argument. OTIF adds the quantity test to on-time.
Some scorecards leave price out on purpose, so the conversation stays on performance [3]. Keep the cost row to price paid against the agreed price, which is a compliance check. The purchase price variance calculator does the arithmetic.
A supplier scorecard example, worked
An example casting supplier, last quarter (invented figures, ours). Weights are ours: 40 for on-time, 30 for quality, 15 each for responsiveness and cost.
Metric (weight) | Result vs target | Points |
|---|---|---|
On-time (40) | 36 of 40 lines, 90% vs 95% | 37.9 |
Quality (30) | 6 of 20,000 rejected, 300 ppm vs 250 | 25.0 |
Responsiveness (15) | 30 hours vs 24 | 12.0 |
Cost (15) | 38 of 40 lines at PO price, 95% vs 98% | 14.5 |
Points = weight × result ÷ target (target ÷ result when lower is better), capped at the weight. Total: 37.9 + 25.0 + 12.0 + 14.5 = 89.4 of 100. Quality is 6 ÷ 20,000 × 1,000,000 = 300 ppm. The score is only useful next to the other suppliers in the same category, and next to what the supplier is told. The free supplier scorecard builds one from your PO history, with its own weights.
What to do this week, with 40 suppliers
Rank the 40 by annual spend (ABC analysis) and score the top 10 to 15 first. The page’s own advice is your 15 to 20 critical suppliers [4].
Pull last quarter from the ERP: confirmed date, receipt date, rejects and price paid.
Show the count next to every percentage. A supplier with 3 of 4 lines late has a small sample, not a 25% record (our rule).
Send each supplier its card with two or three lines to fix.
How supplier performance management works, step by step
Define good. Agree targets with operations, quality and finance before scoring anyone [2].
Pick few metrics. Start with five to eight at most; four is enough to begin [2].
Feed it from your systems. Pull dates and receipts from the ERP, rejects from quality.
Run a cadence. Monthly for delivery and quality, quarterly business reviews for cost and improvement plans [2].
Improve or exit. Agree corrective actions with a due date and track them; move volume to better suppliers when they do not close [2].
Focus on your 15 to 20 critical suppliers first [4].
How plants and distributors use it
A plant uses it to decide who gets the volume and to open corrective actions on rejects. In the IndustryWeek example, the two best-scoring suppliers in each commodity group received about 70% and 30% of the volume [3]. A distributor uses on-time and fill rate to decide which vendor gets the reorder when two stock the same item, and to prepare the vendor’s annual review.
Supplier performance management vs supplier relationship management
SPM measures and improves performance. Supplier relationship management (SRM) is broader: collaboration, risk and innovation. They complement each other [2]. A scorecard’s risk section tracks things like audit status and whether a supplier’s certifications are current [2]; that is the part “supplier risk and performance management” adds.
SPM software and tools
Small teams run it from an ERP report and a spreadsheet. As suppliers and plants multiply, platforms sold as supplier risk and performance management software add automated KPI feeds, supplier portals and risk data. See supplier management software for the options. Neither a spreadsheet nor a platform acts on the numbers: someone still has to talk to the supplier.
Common supplier performance mistakes
Too many metrics. Nobody reads a 20-line card.
Scoring against your wish date. Use the confirmed date.
A scorecard the supplier never sees. Share it, with the two or three lines to fix.
No trigger for action. The IndustryWeek example: after two months at 90% to 92% on time, the supplier presents a plan within 30 days; under 90%, an immediate plan within 15 days [3]. Pick yours.
Letting price drown the rest. Review price on its own agenda.
A scorecard that keeps itself current
A scorecard built by hand is out of date by the next month. Morsa builds it from what already exists:
It scores each supplier from your POs, receipts and email threads, including how fast they reply, and keeps the card current.
When a supplier keeps slipping, it says so, shows the orders at risk and suggests a second quote on the part that matters.
Under a chasing rule the buyer approves once, it asks for confirmed dates from the buyer’s mailbox and writes the answers into the ERP.
To see it on your suppliers, book a 30-minute walkthrough.
Related terms
Operations glossary: every term.
Lead time: how long a supplier takes, which sets the date you ask for.
MOQ: the minimum a supplier will ship, tracked per supplier.
Should cost analysis: checking whether a supplier’s price is fair.
ABC analysis: which suppliers to score first, by spend.
Sources
MRPeasy, Supplier Performance Management Best Practices (a software vendor): https://www.mrpeasy.com/blog/supplier-performance-management (read 12 November 2026)
Kodiak Hub, Supplier Performance Management: Definition, Process, KPIs and Benefits (a software vendor): https://www.kodiakhub.com/blog/supplier-performance-management (read 12 November 2026)
IndustryWeek, Supplier Scorecards: Choose These Metrics to Improve Your Partners’ Performance (Larry Fast, 17 August 2018): https://www.industryweek.com/supply-chain/article/22026195/supplier-scorecards-choose-these-metrics-to-improve-your-partners-performance (read 12 November 2026)
Graphite Connect, Supplier Scorecard Criteria (a software vendor): https://www.graphiteconnect.com/blog/5-supplier-performance-criteria-every-scorecard-should-include (read 12 November 2026)

