Glossary

Glossary

Glossary

Should cost analysis: how to build a should cost model, with an example

Should cost analysis estimates what a part should cost by building it up from material, labor, machine time, overhead and a fair profit, then compares that figure with the supplier's quote. The gap between the two, not the model itself, is the agenda for the negotiation.

6 min

Morsa publishes this guide. Morsa is software with an AI agent that works in your ERP, email and Teams; it builds should-costs, and a person approves what goes out.

Should cost model: the build-up, with a worked example

Should cost = material + labor + setup + machine time + overhead + outside processing + logistics + fair profit [1]

An estimate, not an audit of the supplier’s books. Art of Procurement quotes a CADDi executive: “Even if you have a rough idea of the four components, material cost, process cost, overhead, and profit, that’s probably enough to start your conversation” [1].

A machined steel bracket, lot of 500. Every rate below is an assumption of ours, including that the $60 machine rate does not already include overhead. Replace them with yours.

Cost element

How it is built

$ per part

Material

4.0 lb blank × $1.50 a lb, plus 5% scrap

6.30

Operator labor

6 minutes at $30 an hour

3.00

Setup

3 hours × $80 an hour ÷ 500 parts

0.48

Machine time

12 minutes at a $60 an hour machine rate

12.00

Overhead

15% of labor, setup and machine time

2.32

Outside finishing

Anodizing, an assumed quote

2.00

Packing and freight

Per part

0.60

Fair profit

10% of the cost above

2.67

Should cost


29.37

Cost before profit is 6.30 + 3.00 + 0.48 + 12.00 + 2.32 + 2.00 + 0.60 = $26.70. Profit is 10% of that, $2.67, so should cost is $29.37.

The supplier quotes $34.50. The gap is $34.50 - $29.37 = $5.13 a part, 17.5% over should cost, or $2,565 on 500 parts. Ask about the biggest line first, machine time. If the supplier’s cycle is 15 minutes and not 12, that is 3 minutes at $1 a minute, $3.00 of the gap, plus the overhead and margin on it. You now have a specific question, not a feeling.

Where the inputs come from

If you do not make the part, Art of Procurement’s template points to these sources [1]: commodity price indices and material specifications for material; process sheets and published labor statistics for labor; equipment specifications and your own engineering and operations colleagues for machine time and cycle time; industry benchmarks for overhead, typically a share of conversion cost; freight quotes for logistics. The sources read do not publish a standard cycle time or machine rate. Treat yours as a first guess and ask the supplier to correct it.

How to run a should cost analysis, step by step

  1. Pick the parts. Roughly 20% of parts carry 80% of the spend. Model those, not the tail [1].

  2. Build the model. Start with material, process, overhead and profit. Use material price indices, wage data and your own engineers’ cycle times [1].

  3. Compare. Put the estimate against the quote and see which line holds the gap. A gap in material starts a different conversation from a gap in overhead [1].

  4. Open the conversation. Share the model as a starting point and ask the supplier to correct it. Their corrections are the cost data you wanted [1].

  5. Set targets over time. The gap rarely closes in one round; agree a path over several years if needed [1].

You can also run the analysis before the request for quotation, to have a benchmark for competing bids [2]. Use it as the benchmark, with one ask: “this is my estimate, where am I wrong?”

Who uses should cost analysis

Buyers and sourcing managers at manufacturers, to challenge quotes on machined, fabricated and molded parts. Cost engineers in larger plants. Distributors buying from manufacturers use it to test a price increase. In the example, material is $6.30 of $29.37. A 10% steel increase adds $0.63, or $0.69 with the 10% profit: 2.4% of the should cost, 2.0% of the $34.50 quote. A manufacturer asking for 8% needs to explain the rest.

Should cost model software: the tool categories

  • A spreadsheet. Enough for the top 20% of parts. The table above is one.

  • Should-cost software. A category that spans spend and cost analytics, CAD-based cost estimation, and platforms that build should-cost models at scale. CADDi, named by Art of Procurement, targets low-volume direct material parts [1]. Use it when you have thousands of parts and a drawing for each.

  • Your ERP’s costing and your quoting history. Past jobs already hold real routings and machine rates; see manufacturing quoting software.

Common should cost mistakes

  1. Chasing precision. Accuracy matters less than what you do with the gap [1].

  2. Leaving the profit out. A fair margin makes the rest of the model credible [1].

  3. Double counting. A machine rate often already includes overhead. Check before adding an overhead line on top.

  4. Modeling the tail. A $0.40 washer is not worth the hour.

  5. Using it as a weapon. Share it as a question, not an attack [1].

Building the should cost from your own jobs

A should cost needs real routings, rates and prices. Morsa pulls them from your ERP and past jobs:

  1. For a new drawing, it reads the part, finds similar past jobs, their routings, machine rates and the current material price, and builds the table above.

  2. When the supplier’s quote arrives, it shows the gap line by line.

  3. The buyer decides what to challenge; Morsa drafts the question to the supplier and sends it from the buyer’s mailbox once approved.

It is not a CAD-based costing platform; for thousands of drawings, use that category. To see it on your parts, book a 30-minute walkthrough.

Related terms

Sources

  1. Art of Procurement, Should-Cost Analysis: My Guide for Procurement (27 August 2026): https://artofprocurement.com/blog/should-cost-analysis-my-guide-for-procurement (read 12 November 2026)

  2. Fairmarkit, Should-Cost Analysis: https://www.fairmarkit.com/glossary/should-cost-analysis (read 12 November 2026)

  3. ControlHub, How to Build a Should Cost Model: https://www.controlhub.com/blog/should-cost-model (read 12 November 2026)

Keep reading

Keep reading

Keep reading

Related pages

Glossary

Glossary

Glossary

Operations glossary: 15 terms for plants and distributors

The operations glossary defines 15 terms that plant managers, buyers and warehouse leads use every week, grouped by planning, purchasing and suppliers, shop floor and warehouse. Each term has a one-line definition here and its own page with a formula or a worked example.

Read the page

›

Glossary

Glossary

Glossary

Supplier performance management: the metrics, a scorecard and how to run it

Supplier performance management (SPM) is measuring every key supplier the same way, on delivery, quality, cost and responsiveness, and acting on the results with the supplier. A typical starting set is on-time delivery, parts per million rejected, price against the PO, and hours to respond.

Read the page

›

Glossary

Glossary

Glossary

MOQ meaning: what minimum order quantity is and how to work with it

MOQ stands for minimum order quantity: the smallest quantity, or order value, a supplier will sell you in one order, such as 500 units or $1,000. If you need 200 units and the MOQ is 500, you buy 500 and carry 300 extra, or you negotiate the minimum down.

Read the page

›

FAQs

FAQs

FAQs

Questions people ask

Questions people ask

Still have a question? A founder will answer.

01

What is should cost analysis?

Estimating a part's cost bottom-up to compare with the price quoted.

02

What is a should cost model?

The table that does it: material, labor, machine time, overhead, logistics and profit, with the assumptions written down.

03

What is should cost modeling used for?

Negotiating a quote, benchmarking bids and testing price increases [1][2].

04

Is there should cost modeling software?

Yes, in categories from cost analytics to CAD-based estimation (above). A spreadsheet is enough to start.

05

What is a fair profit margin to include?

Art of Procurement mentions sector benchmarks, often around 10% EBIT, and says a supplier's margin is typically around 10% of total cost [1]. Check your own category.

06

What data do I need?

Weights and material prices, cycle times, labor and machine rates, an overhead rate, and quotes for outside processes [3].

Where Morsa fits

Where Morsa fits

Where Morsa fits

Find out where AI could make your plant more money.

Answer a few questions about your plant. We come back with a free Manufacturing AI Profitability Plan, and we tell you honestly if we are not the right fit.

Machines, people, and vendors, finally in one. We start with yours.

For queries, feedback or suggestions

© 2026 Morsa. All Rights Reserved. A Product by Lunar.

Machines, people, and vendors, finally in one. We start with yours.

For queries, feedback or suggestions

© 2026 Morsa. All Rights Reserved. A Product by Lunar.

Machines, people, and vendors, finally in one. We start with yours.

For queries, feedback or suggestions

© 2026 Morsa. All Rights Reserved. A Product by Lunar.